[chirp_users] Rules, Radio capabilities, and CHIRP capabilities
Colleagues: Our community is interested in three different things, and I feel we need to do a better job of separating them, because different folks have different situations.
Rules: we are not all US Hams. Some are not US and some are not Hams. the rules and regulations differ by jurisdiction and depend on both the hardware you are using and the licences you hold. It may (or may not) be useful to comment on the rules, but when you do, please make sure you mention which jurisdiction, licence, and hardware.
Radio capabilities: Each radio has its own hardware capabilities. Some of these capabilities interact with the rules in some jurisdictions, and sometimes rules change. There is no reason we cannot discuss hardware capabilities independently of the rules, since those capabilities are still usable in some jurisdictions and/or to some users under some circumstances.
CHIRP capabilities: Hey, this is the CHIRP user group! We can and should discuss any CHIRP capabilities that may be usable by some CHIRP users in some situations. It is the responsibility of each user to understand the governing rules. It is not the responsibility of the CHIRP software or the CHIRP user community to attempt to enforce these rules, especially since the rules you are trying to enforce may not be applicable to the users you are addressing. A brief sentence to note that a particular capability may violate a rule in a particular situation may be acceptable if it becomes obvious that the user might need the reminder.
(Thanks for your attention. I will get down off of my soapbox now.)
Point well taken. We are not a group of enforcers; but we are a group of educators. We should neither encourage nor discourage behavior. But we should take the opportunity to educate. Every radio operator, regardless of jurisdiction, should know the rules and make a conscious choice as to whether or not to obey them, understanding that actions have consequences. Chris, N1CAK
On 6/24/2019 10:19 AM, Dan Clemmensen wrote:
Colleagues: Our community is interested in three different things, and I feel we need to do a better job of separating them, because different folks have different situations.
Rules: we are not all US Hams. Some are not US and some are not Hams. the rules and regulations differ by jurisdiction and depend on both the hardware you are using and the licences you hold. It may (or may not) be useful to comment on the rules, but when you do, please make sure you mention which jurisdiction, licence, and hardware.
Radio capabilities: Each radio has its own hardware capabilities. Some of these capabilities interact with the rules in some jurisdictions, and sometimes rules change. There is no reason we cannot discuss hardware capabilities independently of the rules, since those capabilities are still usable in some jurisdictions and/or to some users under some circumstances.
CHIRP capabilities: Hey, this is the CHIRP user group! We can and should discuss any CHIRP capabilities that may be usable by some CHIRP users in some situations. It is the responsibility of each user to understand the governing rules. It is not the responsibility of the CHIRP software or the CHIRP user community to attempt to enforce these rules, especially since the rules you are trying to enforce may not be applicable to the users you are addressing. A brief sentence to note that a particular capability may violate a rule in a particular situation may be acceptable if it becomes obvious that the user might need the reminder.
(Thanks for your attention. I will get down off of my soapbox now.)
chirp_users mailing list chirp_users@intrepid.danplanet.com http://intrepid.danplanet.com/mailman/listinfo/chirp_users This message was sent to Christopher Knowles at cknowles@tiac.net To unsubscribe, send an email to chirp_users-unsubscribe@intrepid.danplanet.com
Very good point, My situation, I work on film sets, sometimes internationally. In my particular case, I need to monitor different bands while being able to transmit on others, carrying multiple radios in Belize in the summer is not an ideal scenario. I perceived the mail list to be a last resort after endless googling, I appreciate the links people sent from google, I had already been there. Those who responded directly, I am most appreciative, the baofeng can do what I need it to, unless the FCC sends someone down to Mayan ruins in the jungle with equipment to find me and my crew, it could be an interesting prosecution.
Chef Todd
FoodJunkie Film Catering
From: Christopher Knowles Sent: Monday, June 24, 2019 10:38 AM To: chirp_users@intrepid.danplanet.com Subject: Re: [chirp_users] Rules, Radio capabilities, and CHIRP capabilities
Point well taken. We are not a group of enforcers; but we are a group of educators. We should neither encourage nor discourage behavior. But we should take the opportunity to educate. Every radio operator, regardless of jurisdiction, should know the rules and make a conscious choice as to whether or not to obey them, understanding that actions have consequences. Chris, N1CAK On 6/24/2019 10:19 AM, Dan Clemmensen wrote: Colleagues: Our community is interested in three different things, and I feel we need to do a better job of separating them, because different folks have different situations.
Rules: we are not all US Hams. Some are not US and some are not Hams. the rules and regulations differ by jurisdiction and depend on both the hardware you are using and the licences you hold. It may (or may not) be useful to comment on the rules, but when you do, please make sure you mention which jurisdiction, licence, and hardware.
Radio capabilities: Each radio has its own hardware capabilities. Some of these capabilities interact with the rules in some jurisdictions, and sometimes rules change. There is no reason we cannot discuss hardware capabilities independently of the rules, since those capabilities are still usable in some jurisdictions and/or to some users under some circumstances.
CHIRP capabilities: Hey, this is the CHIRP user group! We can and should discuss any CHIRP capabilities that may be usable by some CHIRP users in some situations. It is the responsibility of each user to understand the governing rules. It is not the responsibility of the CHIRP software or the CHIRP user community to attempt to enforce these rules, especially since the rules you are trying to enforce may not be applicable to the users you are addressing. A brief sentence to note that a particular capability may violate a rule in a particular situation may be acceptable if it becomes obvious that the user might need the reminder.
(Thanks for your attention. I will get down off of my soapbox now.)
_______________________________________________ chirp_users mailing list chirp_users@intrepid.danplanet.com http://intrepid.danplanet.com/mailman/listinfo/chirp_users This message was sent to Christopher Knowles at cknowles@tiac.net To unsubscribe, send an email to chirp_users-unsubscribe@intrepid.danplanet.com
participants (3)
-
Christopher Knowles -
Dan Clemmensen -
Todd J. Unkefer