[chirp_devel] Failure Communicating with Wouxun KG-UVD1P
Dear Chirp Developers:
Back in 2009, I purchased a few Wouxun KG-UVD1P units (firmware version unknown) and they used to work quite well with Chirp "stable" up until around 2012 or 2013 or so. Now, on various versions of Ubuntu and Debian machines I have tried, Chirp can no longer communicate with these radios either to download new data or to upload anything based on an old image file. I suspected my programming cables--the drivers and/or the firmware faeries.
However, just last month, in addition to switching my desktop over to Ubuntu 14.04.1 LTS amd64, I also purchased some new Baofeng UV-5R units (firmware version BFS297) and installed the Chirp "daily" build 20140724 and can confirm that there were zero problems programming them using my old Prolific PL2303 programming cables (not to be confused with the PL2303HX which this isn't--those also seem to work just fine under Linux).
I can't say for sure when things stopped working for my Wouxun units since I generally don't reprogram these units every day--stuff always happens on the same few repeaters all the time, I tend to forget my desktop at home while playing radio, I also know how to program them manually and my cloning cable still worked just fine so meh. Nobody else raised any similar Chirp bugs about it and nobody else was complaining about it on da interweeebz so it seemed that the problem must be on my end.
I have retained a working image file for my old Wouxun units from around 2012 when the old version of Chirp used to communicate fine with them and a recent image file from a working Baofeng unit with a similar set of programmed memories (and fewer mistakes). Hexdumps do not immediately tell me very much from these image files until I learn to read the Chirp code better. I have also extracted a brand new ~/.chirp/debug.log from a failed communication attempt with an old Wouxun unit and a working communication attempt with a new Baofeng unit--both on the same computer, using the same version of Chirp and with the same programming cable.
I would love to know if this failure might be something simple (where I might have a chance in hell of fixing it--maybe the byte preamble is just broken) or if this is something that folks already know about (where I might have a chance of helping someone smarter than me to fix it by providing more binary dumps or test out patches or offer other similar assistance) or else this is a simple "user too stupid" error (which I can also try to help repair by fixing the documentation).
Mostly, I really just want to know if this is a "unknown problem; please raise a ticket" or else this is a "known problem; won't fix" and that I should simply recycle my old Wouxun units into fixed-frequency packet-only transceivers (or lend/donate them to another developer) and stick with hand-helds that I can actually program properly. I would also very much enjoy contributing back to Chirp to make it even better once I get a bit more traction and a few practice patches accepted (i.e.: issue #1801).
Thank you and 73,
Tyler Tidman VA3DGN
I thought I had similar problems until I realised I needed to push the connector into the radio very very hard ! I used a freshly downloaded CHIRP the other month to program my pair of UVD1P handhelds with no problems. I am not saying it could not be a software bug, maybe I just got lucky... but please check cable is well seated into the radio, also try the transfer a few times as the first one can fail.
Jon
On Mon, Aug 4, 2014 at 11:51 AM, Tyler Tidman tyler.tidman@draak.ca wrote:
Dear Chirp Developers:
Back in 2009, I purchased a few Wouxun KG-UVD1P units (firmware version unknown) and they used to work quite well with Chirp "stable" up until around 2012 or 2013 or so. Now, on various versions of Ubuntu and Debian machines I have tried, Chirp can no longer communicate with these radios either to download new data or to upload anything based on an old image file. I suspected my programming cables--the drivers and/or the firmware faeries.
{snipped}
Thank you and 73,
Tyler Tidman VA3DGN
Tyler,
I agree with Jon. There is no indication of communication in the debug.log. If you left the cable out of the radio you would get the same error. I'd say double check the connection between the programming cable and the KG-UVD1P. You might try a little pressure on the plug while you attempt the download.
Jim KC9HI
Well, I'll be... It turns out that this was, in fact, a "user too stupid error". Maybe my punishment should be writing the "how to plug in a cable" section of the users' guide which will also include a "hey, did you try cleaning the metal conductors yet?" tip as well.
The helpful advice received here from Jon and Jim did the job though and I successfully got stuff working for my Wouxuns again--I really need to clamp down on that poor little thing now and twist it to one side to make it work. Maybe this kind of plastic shrinks a fair bit over 5 years.
At any rate... Woohoo! Thanks a bunch.
Tyler VA3DGN
On August 4, 2014 7:28:26 PM EDT, Jim Unroe rock.unroe@gmail.com wrote:
On Mon, Aug 4, 2014 at 11:51 AM, Tyler Tidman tyler.tidman@draak.ca wrote:
Dear Chirp Developers:
Back in 2009, I purchased a few Wouxun KG-UVD1P units (firmware
version
unknown) and they used to work quite well with Chirp "stable" up
until
around 2012 or 2013 or so. Now, on various versions of Ubuntu and Debian machines I have tried, Chirp can no longer communicate with
these
radios either to download new data or to upload anything based on an
old
image file. I suspected my programming cables--the drivers and/or
the
firmware faeries.
{snipped}
Thank you and 73,
Tyler Tidman VA3DGN
Tyler,
I agree with Jon. There is no indication of communication in the debug.log. If you left the cable out of the radio you would get the same error. I'd say double check the connection between the programming cable and the KG-UVD1P. You might try a little pressure on the plug while you attempt the download.
Jim KC9HI
participants (3)
-
Jim Unroe
-
jon
-
Tyler Tidman